Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Hollywood Whitewashing

I was talking to one of my friends last week and he told me how a white actor was cast as Light Yagami in the upcoming American film adaptation of Death Note. For those who don't know, Death Note is about a Japanese teenager who finds a special notebook that can kill anybody as long as you write someone's name in the book. I remember it was the first manga I ever read, and I got swept immediately. Death Note was the one that got me hooked into the manga craze and has a special place in my heart. I enjoyed it so much that I watched all three Japanese movies on Death Note.

I was very shocked when my friend told me that a white actor was going to play Light Yagami. Nat Wolff, a talented actor who was in The Fault in Our Stars was chosen to play Light. There is nothing wrong with Nat, but it just doesn't feel right for a white actor to play a Japanese character. Given, it is an American adaptation of the manga, but I would still expect the directors to pick a Japanese person to play Light. Especially since there aren't even that many Asian roles in Hollywood to begin with, the picking of a white actor to play Light decreases the availability of Asian roles even more. I will be looking forward to watching this movie not because I want to see it, but because I want to see how Nat portrays Light Yagami.  

3 comments:

  1. Hi Frankie,

    I was also extremely excited to see this movie too, but I am really disappointed that they decided to whitewash this movie and not star an Asian lead. I'm sure they'll cast Misa as an Asian character to further the stereotypes on Asian Women.

    I really don't understand their logic behind this casting choice as many movies who have followed this path has failed both critically and financially. I was also really excited for The Last Airbender movie, but they whitewashed that movie as well and it turned out to be a total disaster. Same thing with Dragonball Evolution and Speedracer. Hollywood has got to stop bleaching us Asians out of our own stories!

    ReplyDelete
  2. There are a lot of criticism from this Asian/Asian-American community about Asian misrepresentation in the American film industry. Many Asian/Asian-Americans are angered by films that seems to replace Asian roles with other actors. However, as an Asian American myself, I don't think this has a completely negative effect on Asian representation in film. Would having a white actor be Light, in a way, help bring two cultures together? Do all characters by Asian authors have to have Asian heritage?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that the casting of white actors in these Hollywood adaptations of anime/manga is an attempt to make the film more accessible to a wider audience rather than to try to just appeal to the Asian community. However, it doesn't mean that it works. For instance, Dragonball Evolution (based off of DragonBall, an anime near and dear to my heart) would have been an awful movie even if they casted an Asian Man as Goku. It doesn't make it any less heartbreaking for the kid in me to see my favorite anime/manga character growing up being very poorly casted in a terrible movie.
    This doesn't mean that Hollywood hasn't been white washing roles. The casting of Scarlet Johanson as the lead in the Ghost in The Shell adaptation (where the lead role being very obviously Japanese) or the casting of Emma Stone as a half Asian character in a recent film are a pretty big slap in the face towards Asians/Asian Americans trying to make it in the entertainment industry. Unfortunately the need for Hollywood to make these adaptation marketable, leaves the Asian community and fans of the source material very disappointed in the final result.

    ReplyDelete